Gráfico usado para indicar artículos de Hablemos de números

Shutdowns aren’t new, nor is market resilience

A look back at nearly 50 years of shutdowns shows that while politics may stall, markets tend to recover—and often thrive.

PorSteve Wyett
1 de octubre de 2025Lectura de 6 minutos

PUNTOS CLAVE

  • Shutdowns have occurred under both parties and various congressional majorities, showing they are not tied to one political side.
  • S&P 500 performance during shutdowns is mixed, but 12-month returns after shutdowns are generally positive, averaging over 12%.
  • Investors are encouraged to stick with their long-term financial plans rather than react to short-term political events.

Now that the U.S. government is in another shutdown-and this one with the potentially higher stakes of some permanent federal job cuts-the question has become: "What is an investor to do?" Without offering specific advice, as everyone's situation is different, let's take history as a potential guide.

Our chart this week displays the dates and durations of government shutdowns since 1976, along with the names of the presidents and the party with the majority in each house of Congress. As we can see, government shutdowns appear to be a bipartisan event. They have occurred under presidents of both parties and with both parties controlling both the House of Representatives and the Senate. This was one of the more interesting aspects of the data. Intuitively, it would seem to make more sense that we would have more disagreements leading to a shutdown if there were mixed leadership between the Executive branch and the Legislative branch in Washington. Instead, the longest shutdown, lasting 34 days, occurred during President Trump's first administration with control of both houses of Congress. And I did not recall the frequency and duration of the multiple shutdowns during the Jimmy Carter administration from 1977 to 1980. And in fairness, President Reagan, the Great Communicator, had a string of shutdowns as well, although they tended to be shorter.

Graph of S&P 500 performance during and after government shutdowns from 1976 to 2018.

Clearly, government shutdowns are not new, nor are they the product of one political party over another. What is also apparent, if we look at the performance of the S&P during, and then twelve months post the shutdown, is that investors are generally not hurt by these actions. It is not surprising that the price action during the shutdown is more mixed. On any given day or week, the market's direction can vary. And any time we lengthen investment horizons, the percentage of positive outcomes goes up, but there have only been three instances of stocks being negative twelve months post a government shutdown, with an average return of over 12%.

Much of this might come from the fact that, despite the reasons for the shutdown, the solution normally results in more government spending and faster economic growth. Does this mean higher government spending is the key to economic growth? Of course not. But higher government spending is additive to growth as measured by GDP, and in the end, stock investors like growth a lot more than austerity.

So, back to the original question, "What is an investor to do?" Stick with the plan you have in place. And if you don't have a plan? Let's talk.

Divulgación

Descargar el informe completo

Obtenga los números entregados en su bandeja de entrada.

Suscríbase (Se abre en una pestaña nueva)

Contenido relacionado

    BOK Financial Corporation es una compañía regional de servicios financieros de más de $50 mil millones cuya casa central se encuentra en Tulsa, Oklahoma, y con más de $105 mil millones de activos bajo su gestión y administración. Las acciones de la compañía se comercializan públicamente en NASDAQ en la bolsa de mercados globales selectos (BOKF). Las participaciones de BOK Financial Corporation incluyen BOKF, NA; BOK Financial Securities, Inc. y BOK Financial Private Wealth, Inc. Las acciones de BOKF, NA incluyen TransFund y Cavanal Hill Investment Management, Inc. BOKF, NA opera divisiones bancarias en ocho estados como: Bank of Albuquerque; Bank of Oklahoma; Bank of Texas y BOK Financial (en Arizona, Arkansas, Colorado, Kansas y Missouri); además de tener oficinas de propósito limitado en Nebraska, Wisconsin, Connecticut y Tennessee. Las entidades en poder de BOK Financial Corporation se denominan periódicamente BOK Financial Corporation Group. A través de sus subsidiarias, BOK Financial Corporation ofrece servicios bancarios comerciales y de consumo, servicios de corretaje, inversión, fideicomisos, iniciación y administración de hipotecas y una red de transferencia electrónica de fondos. Para más información, visite www.bokf.com.

    Los servicios de títulos, seguros y asesoramiento se ofrecen a través de BOK Financial Securities, Inc., miembro de  FINRA/SIPC y un asesor de inversiones registrado en la SEC. Los servicios pueden prestarse bajo nuestro nombre comercial, BOK Financial Advisors.

    Todas las inversiones implican un riesgo, incluso la pérdida de capital. El desempeño pasado no garantiza resultados futuros. No hay garantías de que el proceso de inversión termine en una inversión exitosa. La asignación de activos y la diversificación no eliminan el riesgo de experimentar pérdidas de inversión. Los riesgos aplicables a cualquier portafolio son aquellos relacionados con sus valores subyacentes.

    PRODUCTOS DE INVERSIONES Y SEGUROS: NO ASEGURADOS POR LA FDIC | SIN AVAL DEL BANCO O SUS AFILIADAS | SIN DEPÓSITOS | SIN SEGURO DE AGENCIAS FEDERALES DEL GOBIERNO | PUEDEN PERDER VALOR.

    El contenido de este artículo tiene fines informativos y educativos solamente, y no debe interpretarse como asesoramiento legal, impositivo o de inversión. Siempre consulte a un profesional financiero, contador o abogado calificado si desea recibir asesoramiento legal, impositivo o sobre inversiones. Ni BOK Financial Corporation ni sus afiliadas ofrecen asesoramiento legal.

    BOK Financial® es una marca comercial de BOKF, NA. Miembro de FDIC. Equal Housing Lender . © 2025 BOKF, NA.